Is Twilight good to read to an eight year old girl?

12 Responses to “Is Twilight good to read to an eight year old girl?”

  1. I’ve seen younger girls reading Twilight around her age, so I don’t see why it would be a problem.

  2. Charlotte Siobhan Cullen on January 31st, 2009 at 5:54 am

    I think you should give it to her to read for herself.

  3. no no no no no read it yourself.

  4. I think it will be alright to read it too her. Maybe you could alter that part in book three a little bit. Or maybe because she’s only eight she won’t understand. You could ask your parent too if it’s all right. Let them read that little part first.

  5. i don’t think she’s old enough.
    there are plenty of other romance stories
    that are more appropriate for her age.

  6. no, i don’t think so. she is too young to really understand love.

  7. No – no one under 13 should read this tripe.

  8. Meyer actually originally wrote Twilight for adults, and some where along the line the focus shifted to more of a young adult crowd. The reading level isn’t very difficult and there are many a readers younger than high school who can breeze through it; however, content-wise I don’t recommend even it to junior high school kids, so I especially wouldn’t read it to an eight year old. That being said it’s your call. You’re the one who can make those decisions, and you’re the one who knows your daughter.

  9. starcrossedvoyager on February 13th, 2009 at 6:54 pm

    I don’t think she would understand some of the emotions… like the obsessive love of imprinting and Edward’s and Bella’s even stronger love. Also, in New Moon, your sister might not understand why Bella would be the way she was.

    And the kissing and stuff as well. It’s a romance novel, after all, and not many eight year olds would be able to get into them.

    I don’t think I’d have enjoyed the book much if I was eight.

  10. Ask your mom/dad, I think it would be fine becouse they don’t really say *** in the book much.If your mom/dad says that you can’t read it to her just skip that part. I tried to get my 8 year old sister to read twilight, then she screamed at me.

  11. NO ABSOLUTELY NOT!!!! Here is a list of books that are appropriate for an 8 year old.

    Kate DiCamillo:
    Because of Winn-Dixie

    Albert Payson Terhune:
    Lad: A Dog

    Wilson Rawls:
    Where the Red Fern Grows

    Jack London:
    The Call of the Wild
    White Fang
    The Sea Wolf

    Rudyard Kipling:
    Just So Stories
    The Jungle Book

    Fred Gibson:
    Old Yeller

    Marjory K. Rawlings:
    The Yearling

    George Selden:
    The Cricket in Times Square

    Roald Dahl:
    Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
    James and the Giant Peach

    Pamela Lyndon Travers:
    Mary Poppins
    Mary Poppins Comes Back
    Mary Poppins Opens the Door
    Mary Poppins in the Park

    James M. Barrie:
    Peter Pan

    Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson:
    Peter and the Shadow Thieves
    Peter and the Starcatchers
    Peter and the Secret of Rundoon

    Lemony Snicket:
    The Bad Beginning
    The Reptile Room
    The Wide Window
    The Miserable Mill
    The Austere Academy
    The Ersatz Elevator
    The Vile Village
    The Hostile Hospital
    The Carnivorous Carnival
    The Slippery Slope
    The Grim Grotto
    The Penultimate Peril
    The End

    Tony Di Terlizzi and Holly Black:
    The Spiderwick Chronicles: The Field Guide
    The Spiderwick Chronicles: The Seeing Stone
    The Spiderwick Chronicles: Lucinda’s Secret
    The Spiderwick Chronicles: The Ironwood Tree
    The Spiderwick Chronicles: The Wrath of Mulgarath
    Beyond the Spiderwick Chronicles: The Nixie’s Song

    Norton Juster:
    The Phantom Tollbooth

    Lewis Carroll:
    Alice in Wonderland

    Hugh Lofting:
    The Story of Dr. Doolittle
    The Voyages of Dr. Doolittle

    Pene DuBois:
    Twenty-One Balloons

    Kathryn Lindskoog and Ranelda Mack Hunsicker, eds.:
    Faerie Gold: Treasures from the Lands of Enchantment

    Cornelia Funke:
    Dragon Rider
    Ingraine the Brave
    Inkheart
    Inkspell
    The Thief Lord

    Brandon Mull:
    Fablehaven
    Rise of the Evening Star
    Grip of the Shadow Plague

    Katherine Peterson:
    Bridge to Terabithia

    Carol Kendall:
    The Gammage Cup
    The Whisper of Glocken

    Eoin Colfer:
    Artemis Fowl
    The Arctic Incident
    The Opal Deception
    The Lost Colony
    The Artemis Fowl Files: A Companion Book
    The Graphic Novel

    Andre Norton:
    The Witch World
    The Web of the Witch World
    Three against the Witch World
    Year of the Unicorn
    Warlock of the Witch World
    Dragon Scale Silver
    Dream Smith
    The Toads of Grimmerale
    Spider Silk
    Sword of Unbelief
    Sarsthor’s Bane

    Ursula K. LeGuin:
    Earthsea
    A Wizard of Earthsea
    The Tombs of Atuan
    The Farthest Shore
    Tehanu
    Tales from Earthsea
    The Other Wind
    Voices

    Madeleine L’Engle:
    A Wrinkle in Time
    A Wind in the Door
    A Swiftly Tilting Planet
    Many Waters
    An Acceptable Time

    Howard Pyle:
    Story of King Arthur and His Knights – There are several collections of stories about King Arthur.

    Roger Lancelyn Green:
    The Adventures of Robin Hood
    King Arthur and His Knights of the Round Table

    John Bunyan:
    Dangerous Journey ( A beautifully illustrated edition of A Pilgrim’s Progress)

    C. S. Lewis:
    The 7 volume Chronicles of Narnia is a tale of good against evil with very definite Christian influences. Lewis was an atheist who because of his friendship with Tolkien became a Christian. This strongly affected his writing.
    The seven books are as follows:
    The Magician’s Nephew
    The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
    The Horse and His Boy
    Prince Caspian
    The Voyage of the Dawn Treader
    The Silver Chair
    The Last Battle

    J. R. R. Tolkien:
    The Hobbit

    Jonathon Swift:
    Gulliver’s Travels

    Daniel Defoe:
    Robinson Crusoe

    Johann Wyss:
    Swiss Family Robinson

    Robert Louis Stevenson:
    Treasure Island
    Kidnapped

    Jules Verne:
    Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea
    Around the World in Eighty Days

    Laura Ingalls Wilder:
    Little House in the Big Woods
    Little House on the Prairie
    Farmer Boy – This is the story Laura wrote about her husband, Almanzo’s childhood in Malone, New York.

    Johanna Spyri:
    Heidi

    Frances Hodgson Burnett:
    The Secret Garden

    Lucy Maud Montgomery:
    Anne of Green Gables

  12. I think it’s a bit mature for an eight year old. She is not quite at the age where she can understand romance like in twilight. Maybe in a few years…Twilight is just such a physically romantic book, not appropriate for an eight year old in my opinion.

Leave a Reply